Consulting Ai –

Having brainstormed a number of ideas which can be found at the start of my research journey, I felt it would be an interesting experiment to see what ChatGPT 3 made of my quest to produce a research paper.  Therefore, I decided to interrogate it to see if it could help pin down a research question for my paper.  The results of the conversation which I have detailed below were certainly extremely useful, but not in quite the way that I expected, or even intended.  Chat GPT3 was very good at coming up with ideas and suggestions evidenced below.  Unfortunately and for some unknown reason each answer left me feeling somewhat ‘flat’.  Indeed, what ChatGPT had actually shown me was that my Time of the Signs information overload topic was going to be a non starter.  Why?… because although I felt a sense of wonder about subliminal information overload in a visual sense, I just could not get excited about researching this topic.  There was a for me, (on reading back the advice from ChatGPT3), a massive disconnect.  I felt that from an art creation perspective information overload could be a great topic.  However the thought of formulating a research paper of the back of this was much more daunting.  The use of ChatGPT3 hadn’t clarified anything for me regarding my initial thing what it had actually done was show me what I didn’t want to do.

Below is the conversation with ChatGPT exactly as it took place.  Although I now know what I don’t want to do I still think ChatGPT3 gave some useful ideas and advice.

Chat GPT3 – A Conversation About Info Overload

In the conversation with ChatGPT3 below, my questions are in italics followed by the response from ChatGPT3.

I would like to produce a art research paper on information overload and how this might be impacting and influencing people – how would I start this and what would a good research question look like?

1 / 1

To start your research paper on information overload and its impact on people, you could follow these steps:

1. Define your research topic: Begin by defining what you mean by “information overload” and how it relates to art. Consider the specific aspects of information overload that you want to explore and how they might be relevant to the art world.
2. Conduct preliminary research: Conduct a literature review to familiarize yourself with existing research on information overload and its effects on people. This can help you identify gaps in the research and areas that need further investigation.
3. Develop a research question: Based on your research, develop a clear and specific research question that addresses your topic. Your research question should be open-ended and require investigation to answer. For example: How does information overload affect artists and their creative processes?
4. Gather data: Conduct research to gather data that will help you answer your research question. This can include surveys, interviews, or observations of artists and art professionals.
5. Analyze data: Once you have gathered your data, analyze it to identify patterns, themes, and trends that will help you answer your research question.
6. Draw conclusions: Based on your analysis, draw conclusions about the impact of information overload on artists and the art world. Consider the implications of your findings for art practice, education, and policy.

A good research question for your art research paper on information overload might be: How does the abundance of information available in the digital age impact artists’ creative processes and the art they produce? This question allows you to explore how information overload affects the creative process and the resulting art, as well as potential solutions to mitigate its effects.

1 / 1

I like that research question, but I’d also like to look at how information overload can be subliminal for example we are bombarded with advertising, we use masses of information in our lives like rembering passwords etc. we are drowning under a weight of sometimes unseen information what might a good research question look like taking the subliminal element into account?

1 / 1

Great idea! Here’s a revised research question that takes the subliminal element of information overload into account:

“How does the subliminal nature of information overload, such as advertising and the use of passwords, impact individuals and their decision-making processes?”

This research question allows you to explore how individuals are impacted by the subliminal nature of information overload in their daily lives, including how it affects their decision-making processes. You could also consider how this impacts their mental and emotional well-being, as well as potential solutions to mitigate the negative effects of subliminal information overload.

1 / 1

How could this question be fine tuned to fit in with the art world?  Please can you generate a research question that will address the subliminal impact of information overload on artists or their work?

1 / 1

Sure! Here’s a revised research question that specifically addresses the subliminal impact of information overload on artists or their work:

“How does the subliminal nature of information overload, such as advertising and social media, impact the creative processes and artworks of contemporary artists?”

This research question allows you to explore how contemporary artists are impacted by the subliminal nature of information overload, including how it affects their creative processes and the resulting artworks. You could also consider how artists are navigating the challenges of subliminal information overload and the role of art in raising awareness of this issue.

1 / 1

Do you know of any artists who are specifically working in this area?

1 / 1

Yes, there are many contemporary artists who are exploring the theme of information overload in their work. Here are a few examples:

1. Trevor Paglen – Paglen’s work often explores the intersection of technology and society. In his series “Adversarially Evolved Hallucinations,” he uses machine learning algorithms to create surreal and abstract images that reflect the overwhelming amount of data that surrounds us.
2. Taryn Simon – Simon’s work often investigates systems of power and control. In her series “Paperwork and the Will of Capital,” she documents the rooms and filing cabinets that hold the documents of global finance, highlighting the overwhelming amount of information that drives the world’s economy.
3. Joshua Citarella – Citarella’s work often explores the impact of social media and the internet on our lives. In his series “Premiere,” he uses manipulated Google Earth imagery to create abstract, dreamlike landscapes that reflect the way we experience the world through our screens.
4. Rafael Lozano-Hemmer – Lozano-Hemmer’s work often combines technology and public space. In his installation “Pulse Room,” he uses the heartbeat of visitors to power a room full of light bulbs, creating a sensory overload that reflects the overwhelming amount of information we encounter every day.

These are just a few examples, but there are many other contemporary artists working in this area as well.

1 / 1

That’s great – I’m just struggling with my actual question I do like the ones you gave me but I’d like something a bit more ‘meaty’ if you know what I mean?  I want a question that is really clever something that fires up the imagination and again all to do with subliminal overload.

1 / 1

Sure, here’s another suggestion for a research question that might be a bit more thought-provoking:

“How does the subliminal nature of information overload in contemporary society affect the role of the artist as a mediator of cultural values and knowledge?”

This research question invites exploration into how the subliminal nature of information overload in contemporary society impacts the role of artists as cultural mediators, whose work often reflects and critiques the values and knowledge of their time. You could consider how artists are responding to and engaging with this overload of information, and how their work is helping to shape cultural narratives and understandings. Additionally, you could explore how art itself is a form of information and how the subliminal nature of information overload impacts the reception and interpretation of art.

1 / 1

Please can you clarify the term cultural mediator?

1 / 1

Certainly! A cultural mediator is someone who helps to bridge the gap between different cultures or communities, often by translating or interpreting cultural values, ideas, or practices. In the context of art, a cultural mediator could be an artist who creates works that reflect or critique the cultural values and norms of a particular time and place, or a curator who brings together works from different cultures or communities to facilitate cross-cultural dialogue and understanding. Cultural mediators can play an important role in shaping the way we understand and engage with the world around us, and their work can often challenge existing power structures and social hierarchies.

1 / 1

Could you give me two really strong examples of artists who the first one hasn’t been subjected to information overload and one that has clearly been subjected to information overload?

1 / 1

I’m not sure if there are any artists who haven’t been subjected to information overload in some way, but I can provide examples of artists who have responded to information overload in different ways:

1. Agnes Martin – Martin was a minimalist painter known for her sparse, grid-like compositions. Her work was often seen as a reaction against the chaos and information overload of modern life. Martin believed that her paintings had the ability to create a sense of calm and clarity, offering viewers a respite from the overwhelming sensory input of the world around them.
2. Cory Arcangel – Arcangel is a contemporary artist who often incorporates technology and digital media into his work. His pieces often reflect the overwhelming amount of information and media that we encounter on a daily basis. For example, in his piece “Photoshop CS: 72 by 110 inches, 300 DPI, RGB, square pixels, default gradient ‘Spectrum’,” he created a large-scale printout of every gradient available in the default version of Adobe Photoshop, highlighting the sheer number of options and information that the software presents to users.

These two artists represent different approaches to information overload in art – Martin’s work offers a sense of simplicity and clarity in response to the chaos of modern life, while Arcangel’s work engages with and reflects the overwhelming amount of information and media that we encounter on a daily basis.

1 / 1

I wonder if artists who were working over the last few centuries would not have been as exposed to information overload?  Who would be a good minimalist painter that would not have experienced the internet and smartphones etc.?

1 / 1

It’s true that artists from previous centuries would not have been exposed to the same level of information overload as we are today, simply because they did not have access to the vast amounts of information that we do. However, they were still influenced by the information and cultural values of their time, and their work often reflects those influences.

In terms of minimalist painters who were working before the advent of the internet and smartphones, some examples include:

1. Ellsworth Kelly – Kelly was an American painter known for his simple, geometric forms and bold use of color. He began his career in the 1940s and continued working until his death in 2015, so he did live to see the rise of the internet and digital technology. However, his work is often seen as a reaction against the visual noise and clutter of modern life, and he sought to create a sense of calm and simplicity through his paintings.
2. Kazimir Malevich – Malevich was a Russian painter who is often credited with creating the first purely abstract painting, “Black Square,” in 1915. His work was influenced by the rapid social and cultural changes of his time, including the rise of industrialization and the Russian Revolution. While he was not directly exposed to the same level of information overload that we experience today, his work reflects the upheavals and transformations of his era.

Both Kelly and Malevich are seen as important figures in the development of minimalist painting, which sought to pare down art to its most essential elements. While they may not have experienced information overload in the same way that we do today, their work is still relevant to contemporary discussions about how art can respond to and reflect the world around us.

1 / 1

I like those examples – do you think people are generally overly subjected to information today as opposed to yesteryear? And do you think that this could be having a major impact on artists?

1 / 1

Yes, I think people today are generally more subjected to information overload than in previous eras, largely due to the widespread availability of technology and the internet. We are constantly bombarded with information and stimuli through our smartphones, social media, news outlets, and other sources, which can make it difficult to focus, process, and retain information.

As for the impact on artists, I believe that information overload can be both a challenge and an opportunity. On one hand, the sheer volume of information and stimuli can be overwhelming, and it can be difficult for artists to find focus and clarity in the midst of all the noise. On the other hand, the availability of information and technology can also inspire new forms of creativity and expression, and can provide artists with a wider range of tools and resources to work with.

Ultimately, I think the impact of information overload on artists will depend on how they choose to respond to it – some may embrace the chaos and incorporate it into their work, while others may seek to create a sense of clarity and simplicity in response to it. Regardless, it is clear that information overload is a significant factor in contemporary culture and society, and is likely to continue shaping artistic expression and innovation in the years to come.

1 / 1

I like the black square idea.  Do you know of a modern day artist who has been subjected to information overload that may have famously painted something similar?

1 / 1

It’s difficult to say if any modern-day artist has painted something similar to Malevich’s “Black Square” in response to information overload, as the concept of minimalism has evolved and taken on many different forms since Malevich’s time. However, there are certainly contemporary artists who are exploring themes related to information overload and its impact on our lives.

One example is the American painter and multimedia artist, Mark Bradford. Bradford’s work often incorporates found materials such as billboards and posters, which he layers and manipulates to create complex and textured compositions. His work has been described as a response to the urban landscape and the overwhelming amount of information and advertising that we encounter on a daily basis. While his work is not necessarily minimalist in the same way as Malevich’s “Black Square,” it does reflect a similar interest in the impact of visual stimuli and the need to create order out of chaos.

1 / 1

I like that idea – order out of chaos.  Could you give me a research question that incorporates order out of chaos within the context of our conversation?

1 / 1

Sure! Here’s a possible research question that incorporates the theme of “order out of chaos” within the context of information overload and its impact on artists:

“How do contemporary artists use strategies of order and simplicity to navigate the chaos and overload of information in our digital age, and how does this reflect broader cultural anxieties and desires for clarity and control?”

1 / 1

Hmm I quite like it but I’d like something more thought provoking to do with information overload and order from chaos – I’d almost like my question to be in the form of a statement that can be proved or disproved?

1 / 1

Okay, how about this statement that could be used as a research question:

“In a world of information overload, is it possible for artists to create meaningful work that simultaneously reflects the chaos of modern life and imposes a sense of order and simplicity?”

This statement/question raises the issue of whether or not artists can successfully address the challenges posed by information overload and create work that is both relevant and impactful, while also expressing a clear perspective and point of view. It also implies the possibility that artists may be able to strike a balance between chaos and order, and suggests that this balance may be a key factor in creating successful and resonant work in the face of information overload.

1 / 1

Thank you.  I think this has given me lots of food for thought and I’ll come back later once I have refined things further.

1 / 1

You’re welcome! I’m glad I could help. Don’t hesitate to reach out if you have any further questions or if there’s anything else I can assist you with. Good luck with your research!

Can you think of a really deep and clever thought provoking research question into art and design or photography?

1 / 1

Here’s a potential research question that could be thought-provoking within the field of art and design:

“To what extent do our cultural biases and preconceptions shape the ways in which we interpret and value visual art and design?”

This question could involve exploring the various cultural and social factors that influence our perceptions and judgments of visual art, such as our upbringing, education, ethnicity, gender, and socio-economic status. It could also involve examining how different cultures and historical periods have valued different types of art and design, and how these values have shifted over time. Additionally, the question could invite researchers to explore how artists and designers themselves grapple with these issues, and how they use their work to challenge or reinforce cultural norms and expectations.

1 / 1

I like it, but I think lots of people will have thought of that one. Can we do one that is still thought provoking, but more original?

1 / 1

Sure, here’s another potential research question that could be thought-provoking within the field of photography:

“How do the ethics of representation in documentary photography intersect with the power dynamics between photographers and their subjects?”

This question could involve exploring the complex ethical issues that arise when photographers document the lives and experiences of other people, particularly those who are marginalized or vulnerable. It could also involve examining how the power dynamics between photographers and their subjects can influence the way that images are produced, consumed, and interpreted. For example, a photographer who has a lot of power and privilege might be more likely to perpetuate stereotypes or exploit their subjects, while a photographer who has less power might struggle to assert their own perspective or tell a nuanced story. Additionally, the question could invite researchers to explore how documentary photography can be used to empower marginalized communities and challenge dominant narratives, as well as the challenges and limitations of doing so.

1 / 1

I’d like something a bit more direct and less airy fairy please.

1 / 1

Certainly, here’s a research question that is more specific:

“What is the impact of the use of unconventional materials on the longevity and preservation of contemporary artwork?”

This question could involve examining how unconventional materials, such as plastics, organic matter, or technology, are being used in contemporary artwork and how they might impact the preservation of the artwork over time. The research could also explore how conservators are adapting to these new materials, and how they might need to adjust their conservation strategies in order to ensure the longevity of contemporary artwork. Additionally, the question could invite researchers to examine the environmental impact of using unconventional materials in artwork and how this might affect their preservation and conservation in the long term.

1 / 1

Yes I like this one too, please can I have another?

1 / 1

Sure, here’s another potential research question that is more direct and specific:

“How can designers create products and systems that are more accessible and inclusive for people with disabilities?”

This question could involve exploring the various design strategies and principles that can be used to create more accessible and inclusive products and systems, such as universal design, assistive technology, and user-centered design. The research could also examine the challenges and limitations of designing for accessibility and inclusivity, such as conflicting user needs and preferences, limited resources, and lack of awareness or understanding of accessibility issues. Additionally, the question could invite researchers to explore the social and economic benefits of designing for accessibility and inclusivity, such as increased user satisfaction and engagement, expanded market opportunities, and improved social equity.

1 / 1

That’s a great one but one of my fellow students is tackling that one – what about unseen things in art? Please can I have a question for that?

1 / 1

Certainly, here’s a potential research question related to unseen things in art:

“How do artists use symbolism and visual cues to represent the unseen in their artwork, and what effect does this have on the viewer’s interpretation and experience of the work?”

This question could involve exploring the various techniques and strategies that artists use to represent the unseen in their artwork, such as the use of shadow, light, or perspective. The research could also examine how the viewer’s perception and interpretation of the work might be influenced by their own beliefs and cultural background, and how this might affect their experience of the work. Additionally, the question could invite researchers to explore the role of art in shaping cultural beliefs and perceptions of the unseen, and how this might evolve over time.

1 / 1

I am finding working out my research question for my thesis really stressful – do you have any suggestions that might help?

1 / 1

Of course! Here are a few tips to help you develop your research question for your thesis:

1. Brainstorm: Start by jotting down any ideas that come to mind, even if they seem far-fetched or incomplete. This can help you identify themes or topics that you’re interested in exploring further.
2. Refine your topic: Once you have a list of potential topics, try to narrow them down and focus on a specific aspect or angle that you want to explore in your research.
3. Consult with your advisor or peers: Reach out to your thesis advisor or other colleagues in your field for guidance and feedback on your topic. They may be able to offer helpful suggestions or point you in the direction of relevant literature or resources.
4. Conduct a literature review: Before finalizing your research question, make sure to do a thorough review of the existing literature in your field. This can help you identify any gaps or areas that haven’t been explored yet, and can also help you refine your research question.
5. Test your question: Once you have a tentative research question, try testing it out by discussing it with others or conducting a pilot study. This can help you identify any potential challenges or limitations with your question and refine it further.

Remember, developing a research question takes time and effort, so don’t be too hard on yourself if it feels overwhelming at first. Take it step by step and reach out for support when you need it.

1 / 1

Thank you so much that is really helpful.  I am finding it hard to think of a suitable research question but I did like your question about visual clues, symbolism and the paranormal as I’m wanting to look into hidden things.  What I would like to know is whether or not our subliminal information overload is having an effect on the art world.  I think that Ai should be in there somewhere too.  Could you think of an Ai research question relating to art?

1 / 1

Sure, here’s a potential research question that could incorporate both subliminal information overload and AI in relation to art:

“How does the use of AI-generated content and subliminal messaging in art affect the viewer’s interpretation and experience of the work?”

This question could involve exploring how artists and designers are using AI to generate content and create new forms of expression in art, as well as the ethical and aesthetic implications of doing so. The research could also examine how the use of subliminal messaging in art, such as through hidden or obscured images or messages, might affect the viewer’s perception and interpretation of the work. Additionally, the question could invite researchers to explore the role of technology and media in shaping our experience of art, and how this might be changing over time.

As you continue to develop your research question, it’s important to keep in mind your research goals, the scope of your study, and the potential impact of your research on your field of study. Good luck with your research!

1 / 1

Are you able to brainstorm with me?

1 / 1

Absolutely, I’d be happy to help you brainstorm some research questions! What topic are you interested in exploring?

1 / 1

Well I’ve been looking at how we are bombarded with information on a daily basis – I want to know if this is having an impact on us humans and if so how is it manifesting itself?  I think some of the information load is subliminal too so I’d like to weave that into my research – I’m just really struggling to link it to art and design or photography – any suggestions would be most helpful.

1 / 1

Certainly! Here are a few potential research questions related to your topic:

1. “How does information overload affect our perception and interpretation of art and design, and how might artists and designers respond to this phenomenon?”
2. “What role does subliminal messaging play in the design and creation of art and how might this influence the viewer’s perception and interpretation of the work?”
3. “How might emerging technologies like artificial intelligence and machine learning help us better understand the impact of information overload on human cognition and behavior?”
4. “To what extent do cultural and societal factors influence our susceptibility to information overload, and how might this affect our interpretation and appreciation of art and design?”

As you can see, each of these questions approaches the topic of information overload from a slightly different angle, while still incorporating the themes of art, design, and photography. Hopefully, one of these questions (or a variation of them) will help you get started on your research!

1 / 1

Yes these are great I think I could adapt some of them please could I have a few more along these lines?

1 / 1

Certainly, here are a few more research questions related to information overload and its potential impact on art, design, or photography:

1. “How does the saturation of digital media and technology impact the way we perceive and interact with physical artworks, and what implications does this have for the future of art and design?”
2. “To what extent do visual cues and symbols in art and design serve as a form of visual shorthand that allows for faster processing of information and more effective communication, and how might this be related to the phenomenon of information overload?”
3. “What techniques and strategies are artists and designers using to help mitigate the effects of information overload in their work, and how effective are these approaches in communicating their intended messages?”
4. “How might advances in cognitive science and neuroscience help us better understand the impact of information overload on our cognitive processes, and what implications might this have for the fields of art and design?”

I hope these additional questions help to further inspire your research!

1 / 1

Thank you! I will go away and study some of these questions – I am really struggling though.  Any suggestions?

1 / 1

If you’re still feeling stuck, here are a few additional tips that might help you develop your research question:

1. Consider the scope of your research: Think about the resources available to you, the time you have to complete your project, and the scope of your research. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, it might be helpful to narrow your focus to a specific aspect of your topic that you find particularly interesting or important.
2. Brainstorm: Take some time to brainstorm a list of potential research questions. Don’t worry about whether they’re good or bad questions at this point – just jot down anything that comes to mind. Once you have a list of questions, you can start to refine and develop them further.
3. Read broadly: Read widely in your field of study and related disciplines to gain a deeper understanding of the research that’s already been done on your topic. This can help you identify gaps in the literature that you might be able to address with your own research.
4. Consult with your advisor or a mentor: If you’re feeling stuck, it can be helpful to talk to someone who’s more experienced in your field of study. Your advisor or a mentor might be able to offer insights or suggestions that you haven’t considered before.

Remember, developing a research question can take time and effort, and it’s okay to feel stuck or uncertain at times. Just keep in mind your research goals, the scope of your study, and the potential impact of your research on your field of study. Good luck with your research!

1 / 1

Thank you so much – this is helpful.

1 / 1

You’re welcome! I’m glad I could be of help. If you have any other questions or concerns, feel free to ask!

End of conversation